5 Clear Signs Your Dog’s Toy Needs Replacing (and How to Choose Safe, Durable Replacements)
As loving dog parents, we want our furry companions to stay safe, happy, and tail-waggingly entertained. A big part of that includes making sure their toys are in tip-top shape. But knowing when it’s time to let go of your dog’s favourite tennis ball or beloved plush toy isn’t always straightforward. In this guide, we’ll walk through the clear signs your dog’s toy needs replacing, why it matters, and how to choose long-lasting, safe replacements — so playtime stays pawsitive!
Why Old Dog Toys Can Be Dangerous
Just like us, dogs can outgrow or wear out their belongings. But when it comes to toys, damage can turn dangerous quickly. Torn seams, loose stuffing, cracked rubber or sharp edges aren’t just unsightly — they can lead to choking, intestinal blockages, or mouth injuries.
In New Zealand, we’re lucky to have access to a wide range of high-quality dog toys that meet pet safety standards. Still, even the best-made toys won’t last forever, especially with enthusiastic chewers. Regular toy checks are a smart habit to keep your pet safe and entertained.
Key Signs It’s Time For a New Toy
- Visible Damage: Holes, cracks, missing parts or unravelled stitches are major red flags.
- Loose Stuffing or Squeakers: A big no-no! Ingested squeakers or stuffing can become veterinary emergencies.
- Sharp Edges or Hardening: Toys made of rubber or plastic can degrade over time, becoming brittle and sharp.
- Excessive Dirt or Mould: If deep cleaning doesn’t do the trick, it’s time to bin it. Mouldy toys can lead to illness.
- Lack of Interest: If your pup gives it the cold shoulder, they may be bored with it. Rotate or replace to keep play fun and stimulating.
As a rule of paw, inspect your dog’s toys weekly and after intense play sessions. Catching wear and tear early is the best way to avoid accidents.
Choosing Safe & Durable Replacements
When picking new toys, think about your dog's size, age, chew style and play preferences. For heavy chewers, opt for tough options like durable chew toys. Puppies, on the other paw, benefit from softer materials that are kind to growing teeth.
Popular choices with Kiwi dog parents include long-lasting designs from trusted brands like KONG and Nylabone. For interactive fun, try interactive toys that keep your dog’s brain buzzing and tail wagging.
Not sure where to start? Check out our top-rated picks for safe, engaging, and well-loved options.
How To Make Toys Last Longer
- Rotate toys: Keep things fresh by offering different toys each week. It prevents boredom and reduces wear on any one favourite.
- Supervise play: Especially with plush and rope toys, keep an eye out during play to prevent destruction or swallowing loose bits.
- Clean regularly: Some toys are dishwasher or machine safe. A quick clean helps prevent bacteria buildup and keeps toys looking (and smelling!) better.
For pups with sensitive gums or teeth, cleaning is especially important. And if your dog tends to get over-excited, you might also consider calming toys or supplements during playtime.
Swap & Save With Petdirect
Replacing worn-out toys doesn’t have to break the bank. At Petdirect, you’ll find a huge range of great value toys for every play style, plus exclusive benefits through our Pet Perks loyalty programme.
Want to make toy shopping easier? Try our Autodeliver service to receive new toys at the push of a paw, right when you need them!
Because at Petdirect, We Get Pet. We know play isn’t just fun — it’s vital to your dog’s happiness, health and development.
Keep Playtime Safe and Tail-Wagging
Dog toys do more than entertain — they support healthy teeth, reduce boredom, and are a key part of enrichment. So keeping them clean, safe, and in good nick is essential. By recognising the signs your dog’s toy needs replacing, and choosing quality, durable alternatives, you'll keep tails wagging and playtime worry-free.
Ready to refresh your pup’s toy box? Explore our full range of dog toys online and treat them to a new favourite today.