How To Choose The Right Toy For Your Cat’s Personality

Just like us, every cat has their own unique personality—some are social butterflies, others are low-key loungers. And when it comes to choosing the right toy for your cat's personality, tapping into their personal play style can deepen your bond, keep boredom at bay, and support their physical and mental wellbeing.

At Petdirect, we get pet. That’s why we’ve created this easy guide to help you choose toys that match your cat's character—whether they’re an energetic explorer, a gentle soul, or something in between. Let's find the purr-fect match!

Why Matching Toys To Your Cat’s Personality Matters

Toys aren’t just about fun—they’re fundamental to a happy, healthy feline life. Cats need mental stimulation, physical activity, and comfort, all of which can come from the right toys. But not every toy will tick the same boxes for every cat. Understanding their preferences means:

• Encouraging more meaningful play
• Promoting exercise that feels natural and fun
• Preventing boredom and destructive behaviours
• Reducing stress and anxiety through calming routines

Choosing toys that suit your cat's personality helps meet their emotional and instinctual needs—so your curious kitty or cuddly companion gets the enrichment they truly crave.

For The Curious Explorer

Curious cats are always on the go, sniffing out things, poking their paws into odd spaces, and generally creating chaos (adorably, of course). These cats thrive on interactivity and love toys that engage their hunting instincts or puzzle-solving skills.

Top toy picks for curious cats:

• Interactive teaser toys and wands — great for jumping, chasing, and bonding with you
• Electronic toys that simulate prey movement
• Puzzle feeders to make treat-time a challenge

If your curious cat tends to get over-excited, supporting their playtime with calming essentials could be a smart move to help smooth those high-energy zoomies.

For The Snuggly Cuddler

Not every cat is a parkour expert. If your feline friend prefers slinking onto your lap rather than the top of the bookcase, their ideal play is softer and slower—and that’s perfectly fine. These cats benefit from toys that offer comfort and gentle stimulation.

Purr-fect picks for snuggly cats:

• Plush toys or soft mice they can bat around or sleep with
• Catnip-infused toys for mellow playtime (and sweet dreams)
• Snuggly bedding accessories that double as a play and nap space

Why not complement their relaxed personality with soothing cat calming care? It's ideal for cats that love routine and reassurance.

For The Independent Hunter

Independent cats love to entertain themselves—and often prefer solo playtime. These natural hunters need toys they can chase, pounce on, and "catch" without relying on you to get involved every time.

Recommended toys for independent cats:

• Rolling balls and chasers to mimic prey scurrying across the floor
• Catnip toys to spark interest and activity
• Motion-activated toys they can stalk at their leisure

Many solo players also appreciate the privacy of a scratching post or climbing tree where they can hide, perch, and survey their domain.

For The Playful Kitten

Kittens are little balls of curiosity, and everything is a game. Choosing toys for young cats means finding ones that are safe, gentle on little teeth and claws, and spark loads of excitement.

Go-to gear for kittens includes:

• Kitten-safe interactive toys that promote healthy physical development
• Soft chew-friendly toys that are small enough for tiny paws
• Feathered wands to help channel all that adorable energy

And if your kitten is teething or still adjusting to their environment, consider soothing options from our calming essentials collection for young feline friends.

How To Build The Purr-fect Toy Box

Once you know your cat’s personality, crafting a well-rounded toy box is simple. Aim for a mix of toys that cover:

• Hunting instincts – balls, wands, puzzles
• Comfort – plush toys, bedding buddies
• Solo and shared play – so your cat gets options whether you’re home or not

Rotate their toys regularly to keep things fresh, and consider introducing new favourites from our new arrivals or top rated picks—your cat’s next obsession might just be a toy away.

Tailored Play For A Happier Cat

Choosing the right toys for your cat isn’t just about keeping them entertained—it’s about understanding who they are. At Petdirect, we get pet: from zoomy adventurers to cuddle-loving loungers, we’ve got every toy type to suit every feline friend.

Ready to find your cat’s new favourite toy? Explore our full range of cat toys and make playtime as unique as your cat is. Don't forget to sign up for our Pet Perks loyalty programme to have access to exclusive deals while treating your kitty to the best!