Dog Collars vs Harnesses: Which One Should You Choose?
Choosing between a dog collar and harness can seem simple, but your decision can impact your dog's safety, comfort, and training. Whether you're walking a small pup around your local neighbourhood or exploring the great outdoors with an energetic Labrador, selecting the right walking gear is crucial. In this guide, we’ll explore the pros and cons of dog collars vs harnesses, so you can choose the best option for your furry friend’s lifestyle and needs.
Understanding Dog Collars: Simple And Convenient
Dog collars are a popular and traditional choice for everyday use. They’re easy to slip on and off, making them ideal for attaching ID tags, registration, and leads. Many pet parents use collars during relaxed walks or when their dog is already lead-trained.
However, collars aren’t suitable for all dogs, especially those prone to pulling. Pressure from the collar can strain the neck and lead to behavioural issues or injuries, particularly in small breeds or brachycephalic dogs like Pugs and French Bulldogs.
Collars can still be a useful tool when paired with appropriate training essentials for puppies or calm adult dogs that walk gently beside you.
Why Harnesses Offer Better Control And Safety
Harnesses distribute pressure across your dog’s chest and shoulders rather than the neck, making them suitable for dogs that pull, lunge, or need behavioural training. A well-fitted harness also provides better control during walks, particularly for large or reactive dogs.
Harnesses can prevent tracheal injuries and are often recommended for dogs with respiratory issues, toy breeds, or very active dogs. Many modern models come with padding and adjustable straps for a secure and comfortable fit.
If you're starting leash training or have a highly excitable pup, consider harnesses part of your puppy starter list.
Choosing The Right Gear For Your Dog’s Breed And Behaviour
When deciding between a collar and harness, consider your dog’s breed, size, activity level, and behaviour on walks. For example:
- Small breeds: Often do better with harnesses due to delicate tracheas
- Large or strong breeds: Harnesses offer more control and durability
- Well-trained or calm dogs: A collar may be sufficient for everyday use
Some pet owners use both—keeping a collar with ID tags on at all times and attaching a harness for walks or training. Explore different types in our wide selection of dog accessories to find the perfect fit for your pet.
Training Considerations And Walking Comfort
Walking your dog should be an enjoyable, stress-free experience. Collars offer simplicity, but may not help if your dog pulls heavily. Harnesses, especially front-clip versions, can support positive behaviours through gentle redirection and greater control.
Building good leash manners takes consistency and the right gear. If your dog gets anxious or overly excited on walks, try combining a harness with calming supplements or behavioural aids from our collection.
Seasonal And Lifestyle Factors To Keep In Mind
Don’t forget about seasonal needs. In summer, opt for breathable mesh harnesses to keep your dog cool. You can browse our curated range of summer dog essentials.
For winter walks, layer a harness-friendly jacket or vest to keep your dog warm. Explore our full range of pet clothing available for colder months.
Collar Or Harness: What’s Best For Your Pet?
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer in the dog collars vs harnesses debate. The right choice depends on your dog’s size, breed, behaviour, and lifestyle. Collars remain convenient for ID and calm walks, while harnesses offer greater safety and control, especially for energetic or anxious dogs.
Explore Petdirect’s wide collection of top-rated walking accessories to find the best fit for your furry friend. Whether you go with a trusty collar, a full-support harness, or both, investing in quality gear ensures happier, safer adventures for you and your pet.
Ready to upgrade your dog's walking gear? Discover our full selection of collars, harnesses, and leads designed for Kiwi pets and their people.
