How to Choose the Best Dog Toy for Your Dog’s Personality and Play Style - Petdirect
Save up to 25% with Autodeliver*
Learn more
My store:
Select store
Menu
  1. Home
  2. Articles
  3. How to Choose the Best Dog Toy for Your Dog’s Personality and Play Style
How to Choose the Best Dog Toy for Your Dog’s Personality and Play Style

How to Choose the Best Dog Toy for Your Dog’s Personality and Play Style

Every dog has a distinct personality—from high-energy fetch fanatics to chill chewers or brainy puzzlers. Choosing the right toy for your dog’s unique vibe makes all the difference when it comes to safe, fun, and enriching playtime. At Petdirect, we get that your pup isn’t just a pet—they're part of the whānau. That’s why we’re here to help match you with toys that really suit your dog’s style.

Understanding Your Dog’s Play Style

Before picking out a toy, take a good look at how your dog naturally plays. Are they a tug-of-war champ or a couch-cuddling softie? Knowing their preferences means you can choose toys that keep them engaged, entertained, and mentally stimulated—without ending up with sad abandoned squeakers under the couch.

  • The Chewer: Loves to gnaw on anything in sight. Look for sturdy chew toys that satisfy their need to chomp while protecting their teeth and jaws.
  • The Fetcher: Obsessed with chasing anything that moves. Durable fetch toys and balls are their perfect match.
  • The Snuggler: Would rather cuddle than chase. Soft plush toys offer comforting companionship.
  • The Thinker: Gets bored quickly and craves a challenge. Interactive toys and brain games help them flex those smarts.

Toys For Energetic Dogs

Got a pup with energy to burn? High-drive breeds like Border Collies, Retrievers, or Staffies need toys that keep up with their zest for life. Think Chuckit! balls or durable tug ropes for tug-of-war marathons. These toys offer physical outlets while encouraging bonding time with their human.

Tug toys are also excellent for training sessions and can strengthen their impulse control—plus, it’s just plain fun for both of you!

Toys For Gentle Or Senior Dogs

Older pups or dogs with a calm temperament may love snuggling more than sprinting. Gentle toys like plush toys give them something soft to interact with. If your dog is in their golden years, choosing toys that are easy on the teeth and joints is key.

Bundle the fun with something to nibble—pairing a plush toy with a soft, chewy treat can be a winning combo that keeps your older dog content and engaged without overdoing it physically.

Toys For Brainy Dogs That Love A Challenge

Highly intelligent breeds like Poodles, Labradors, and working dogs thrive when their minds are kept busy. Their ideal toy? One that makes them think. Interactive puzzle toys keep them guessing (and away from chewing your shoes).

Look for mentally stimulating activities, like toys by Nina Ottosson, specially designed to spark curiosity and beat boredom. These toys are great for rainy days indoors or when your dog needs some quiet, focused play.

Toys For Chewers With Powerful Jaws

For dogs that love to gnaw all day long, durability is everything. Power chewers need tough toys like those from Benebone or classic favourites like KONG. These toys are tough enough to stand up to regular chewing and can support oral health by keeping teeth clean and strong.

If your pup tends to destroy less rugged toys in seconds, stick with designs rated for aggressive chewers. Look for textured finishes or stuffable toys that you can fill with treats to add another layer of engagement without sacrificing strength.

Safety And Quality Matter

Not all toys are created equal. Whether you’re buying an interactive feeder or a fun squeaker, always choose quality dog toys from trusted brands. At Petdirect, our toy range includes options designed with NZ dog safety regulations in mind and are made to withstand your pup’s play routine.

Each toy is a chance to nurture your dog’s wellbeing—mentally, physically, and emotionally. That’s why we make it easy to find top-rated picks and great value toys no matter your dog’s personality or play style.

Tailor Playtime To Your Dog’s Personality

Dog toys aren’t one-size-fits-all. Matching your dog with the right toy means more tail wags, fewer chewed shoes, and happier, healthier pups. From interactive puzzles to classic fetch favourites, the best toy is one that fits your dog’s energy, age, and personality.

Ready to discover your dog’s new favourite toy? Explore our wide range of dog toys online or in-store, and don’t forget to join our Pet Perks programme to earn rewards while you spoil your furry best mate. Because at Petdirect, We Get Pet.